• Home
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google +
  • Flickr
  • You Tube
  • Nick Bastian

Rail Life

Phoenix Light Rail News and Information

  • About RailLife
  • Events
  • Homes Near Light Rail
  • Phoenix Light Rail Map
You are here: Home / Phoenix Light Rail / Can Public AND Private Money Be Used For Passenger Rail?

Can Public AND Private Money Be Used For Passenger Rail?

July 19, 2011 by Rail Life Leave a Comment

New Report Examines Whether Passenger Rail in Arizona and the U.S. Should Be Public, Private or Both

A first-of-its-kind report released today examines whether high-speed rail should be public, private or both. The research report released by the Arizona PIRG Education Fund examines the experience with public-private partnerships for high-speed rail in the U.S. and other countries.  In addition to outlining the promise and pitfalls, the report recommends ten principles to protect taxpayers and the public interest under private financing deals.

The report comes after the State Transportation Board in Arizona approved a historic State Rail Plan in March 2011 and as the Arizona Department of Transportation is developing plans for linking Phoenix and Tucson via passenger rail. There is also a heated debate in Congress about future funding for high-speed rail and the U.S. House Transportation and Infrastructure chair has proposed privatizing Amtrak with the hope of garnering private financing for new bullet trains along the Northeast. California is seeking private funds as part of a planned route connecting Los Angeles and San Francisco.

“Private financing can be a supplement, but not a substitute, for public commitments to support passenger rail,” said Serena Unrein, Public Interest Advocate for the Arizona PIRG Education Fund. “As Arizona develops plans for our future transportation infrastructure, it is important to factor in how the public’s interest will be protected in any public-private partnership deals.”

The report cautions that public-private partnerships in other countries have often run into trouble. When private financing has been used as a short-cut around public funding, taxpayers often end up paying. Partnerships must have the highest levels of transparency, clear rules of accountability, and strong public capacity for monitoring and enforcing agreements, according to the Arizona PIRG Education Fund. “In other nations the majority of support for rail comes from the public sector. The rail companies overseas often have public ownership and the public on their board like a public utility or Amtrak,” said Unrein.

Arizona’s new State Rail Plan follows a national trend of looking to passenger rail as a way to improve infrastructure.  President Obama has put forth the goal of linking 80 percent of the U.S. population via high-speed rail by 2035. Compared to the U.S., other industrialized nations around the globe tend to be far ahead of the U.S. in developing high-speed rail and invest a far greater portion of Gross Domestic Product on infrastructure.

“While many in Congress and Arizona are having trouble finding money to invest in public transportation, they need to consider the costs of not moving forward,” said Unrein. “Passenger rail is a necessity to connect Arizona because we will reach a point where we cannot build more airport runways or further expand our highways.”

The report is available for download from Arizona PIRG. Here is a small sample of what is mentioned:

“Public-private rail partnerships have the potential to tap private capital, expertise, technology and economies of scale, and can also help mitigate the risk of high-speed rail projects to taxpayers. However, PPPs also come with a number of risks and costs, including:

  • Higher costs for capital, as well as costs related to the profits paid to private shareholders.
  • Heightened risk for the public once a project has begun, due to the ability of private-sector actors to hold projects hostage and demand increased subsidies or other concessions from government.
  • The costs of hiring and retaining the lawyers, financial experts and engineers needed to protect the public interest in the negotiation of PPP agreements and to enforce those agreements over time.
  • Loss of control over the operation of the high-speed rail line, which can result in important transportation assets being operated primarily to boost private profit rather than best advance public needs.
  • Delays in the early stages of a project, as government and private partners engage in the difficult and complex task of negotiating PPP agreements.”

Filed Under: Phoenix Light Rail Tagged With: high speed rail, passenger rail, PIRG

About Rail Life

Here at RailLife.com we like to say, Your Life Is On The Line! We enjoy talkin events, restaurants, real estate and cool stuff along the Phoenix light rail line:
Please have some fun and follow along with us on Twitter!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RailLife

Thanks for visiting RailLife.com! We want to be your resource for all that is light rail in Arizona. Here, we share information about “life along the line.” Feel free to cruise around and to bookmark the site as information is added or changed often!

RailLife Uber Code

Good for $20 off your first ride with Uber! Use Promo code: RAILLIFE OR click here to get an Uber account: RailLife Sign up code

Search RailLife

Search for Homes

Looking for a home? Search NickBastian.com for your future home.

Homes Near Light Rail

41 Listings
516 W Lewis Avenue, Phoenix, AZ 85003

$595,000 516 W Lewis Avenue
Phoenix, AZ 85003

230 E ORANGE Drive, Phoenix, AZ 85012

$749,900 230 E ORANGE Drive
Phoenix, AZ 85012

1135 W GEORGIA Avenue, Phoenix, AZ 85013

$399,999 1135 W GEORGIA Avenue
Phoenix, AZ 85013

529 W 3RD Place, Mesa, AZ 85201

$380,000 529 W 3RD Place
Mesa, AZ 85201

341 E MONTE VISTA Road, Phoenix, AZ 85004

$8,500,000 341 E MONTE VISTA Road
Phoenix, AZ 85004

Great Curb Appeal re-landscaped Jan 2019 w/low volt lighting

$588,000 915 W GEORGIA Avenue
Phoenix, AZ 85013

previous next

MLS IDX Listing Disclosure © 2023

Copyright 2023 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Information Not Guaranteed and Must Be Confirmed by End User. Site contains live data.

Lakeside Living

8 Listings
420 W 1ST Street, 217, Tempe, AZ 85281

$440,000 420 W 1ST Street, 217
Tempe, AZ 85281

945 E PLAYA DEL NORTE Drive, 2007, Tempe, AZ 85288

$449,900 945 E PLAYA DEL NORTE Drive, 2007
Tempe, AZ 85288

140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 1005, Tempe, AZ 85281

$480,000 140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 1005
Tempe, AZ 85281

140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 203, Tempe, AZ 85281

$1,050,900 140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 203
Tempe, AZ 85281

420 W 1ST Street, 323, Tempe, AZ 85281

$460,000 420 W 1ST Street, 323
Tempe, AZ 85281

945 E Playa Del Norte Drive, 1015, Tempe, AZ 85288

$485,000 945 E Playa Del Norte Drive, 1015
Tempe, AZ 85288

previous next

MLS IDX Listing Disclosure © 2023

Copyright 2023 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Information Not Guaranteed and Must Be Confirmed by End User. Site contains live data.

RailLife Posts

Looking For A REALTOR To Rock The Rail Life

Nowhere To Eat In Downtown Mesa

Could Coyotes Help Expand Tempe Streetcar?

Scott Smith Remaining as Valley Metro CEO

Banta Lawyers Up – Sues Valley Metro for $1.65 Million

© 2023 · RailLife · Developed by Marketing Press