• Home
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google +
  • Flickr
  • You Tube
  • Nick Bastian

Rail Life

Phoenix Light Rail News and Information

  • About RailLife
  • Events
  • Homes Near Light Rail
  • Phoenix Light Rail Map
You are here: Home / Homes Near Light Rail / I-10 West light rail discussion brings out NIMBY’s?

I-10 West light rail discussion brings out NIMBY’s?

November 3, 2009 by Nick Bastian 2 Comments

Last week, I attended another METRO I-10 West study meeting to learn more about the light rail extension plans which will take light rail from the existing line and travel out the middle of I-10 to (approximately) 79th Avenue. How to get to I-10 is a big topic of discussion. The reasoning for traveling along the I-10 freeway instead of surface streets like the existing light rail line  is interesting, as well, but that decision appears to have been made. I imagine politics, posturing and funding have a LOT to do with that part of the decision.

There looks to be a few options still on the table with Adams and Jefferson Streets getting the most serious looks. These options run West from the existing line in downtown Phoenix and head towards the I-17 (possibly along the western frontage road?) where it will go north to I-10 and then West.

The Adams and Jefferson routes take people past the Arizona State Capitol, Bolin Memorial Park, Arizona Supreme Court etc.

All of the I-10 West extension meetings have been attended by people living in the “St Matthew” neighborhood. This is an area that will be effected by light rail running down Adams OR Jefferson. The discussion focuses on many topics, with the width of the streets and the new bridge needed at 19th Avenue to cross the railroad tracks being two that get a lot of attention.

While residents ( only about 3-4 in attendance) of the area had good questions, there seemed to be a “we are not sure we want this thing” type of reaction. The bridge will be unsightly to a few of the homes, the traffic could be negatively impacted, what will happen to their neighborhood, etc. are all great things to think about, but I didn’t get the feeling they have looked at all of the positive things occurring along the existing 20 mile stretch of light rail.

I recall a man at the last I-10 West meeting telling me that homes near light rail in that area would be negatively impacted by the light rail. I had to respectfully disagree.  From what I gathered, many people living in the St Matthews area are long time residents and they are not big on change. With re-development, the area will most likely see new business, new homes ( there looks to be a lot of empty lots near by), and new faces looking for convenience to jobs, sporting activities, the arts and the conveniences of light rail. Is it harsh to say that the few homes that could end up facing a bridge are just a necessary effect of growth and change for an entire region?

Once the final route decision has been made and Metro is able to bring more concrete information to the neighborhoods, it will be interesting to follow the reactions. Projects of this size require huge construction phases and disruption of areas for quite some time. Will the neighborhoods look forward to the future or will they fight it? Will the “Not In My Back Yard” crowd come out or will there be dancing in the streets? It is still too early to tell. The I-10 West project was scheduled for a 2019 opening but has been pushed back to “at least” 2021 due to the economic environment.

Knowing that a change is coming, it will be fun to watch the area and to get a better feel for the neighborhoods wants and desires. These discussions at the meeting focused mainly on the part of town West of 19th Avenue between Adams and Jefferson. If you know anyone familiar with or living near by, I would love to hear some thoughts.

Filed Under: Homes Near Light Rail, Light Rail, Phoenix Light Rail Tagged With: Homes Near Light Rail, light rail extension, Metro Light Rail, Phoenix Light Rail, Rail Life

About Nick Bastian

Nick Bastian is a 29 year veteran of the real estate industry and can be reached at 602-803-6425. You'll also find him sharing real estate info on his web site and hanging out onTwitter.
Family man, lover of life, maker of friends. A bit of a geek, long time Tempe real estate guy just havin' some fun. What's your story?

Comments

  1. fpteditors says

    November 3, 2009 at 2:25 pm

    We keep trying to wedge rail fixes into a a broken auto system. First: stop subsidizing the auto and sprawl. Remove the fares from urban public transit, they exist to discourage use and reduce the value of the public investment in transit and thus are an autosprawl subsidy! Then the market will start to level. The town center will re-juvenate. Parking problems will gradually recede. Bicyclists make even be able to travel safely…. In short: no more peaceful coexistence with subsidized autosprawl.

    Reply
  2. fpteditors says

    November 3, 2009 at 7:25 pm

    We keep trying to wedge rail fixes into a a broken auto system. First: stop subsidizing the auto and sprawl. Remove the fares from urban public transit, they exist to discourage use and reduce the value of the public investment in transit and thus are an autosprawl subsidy! Then the market will start to level. The town center will re-juvenate. Parking problems will gradually recede. Bicyclists make even be able to travel safely…. In short: no more peaceful coexistence with subsidized autosprawl.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RailLife

Thanks for visiting RailLife.com! We want to be your resource for all that is light rail in Arizona. Here, we share information about “life along the line.” Feel free to cruise around and to bookmark the site as information is added or changed often!

RailLife Uber Code

Good for $20 off your first ride with Uber! Use Promo code: RAILLIFE OR click here to get an Uber account: RailLife Sign up code

Search RailLife

Search for Homes

Looking for a home? Search NickBastian.com for your future home.

Homes Near Light Rail

36 Listings
Plenty of carport and slab parking space.

$690,000 2023 W RANCHO Drive
Phoenix, AZ 85015

5130 N 6TH Street, Phoenix, AZ 85012

$1,199,000 5130 N 6TH Street
Phoenix, AZ 85012

1315 W ORANGE Drive, Phoenix, AZ 85013

$599,900 1315 W ORANGE Drive
Phoenix, AZ 85013

406 N 12TH Street, Phoenix, AZ 85006

$739,000 406 N 12TH Street
Phoenix, AZ 85006

420 N 11TH Street, Phoenix, AZ 85006

$459,990 420 N 11TH Street
Phoenix, AZ 85006

1220 W HIGHLAND Avenue, Phoenix, AZ 85013

$400,000 1220 W HIGHLAND Avenue
Phoenix, AZ 85013

previous next

MLS IDX Listing Disclosure © 2023

Copyright 2023 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Information Not Guaranteed and Must Be Confirmed by End User. Site contains live data.

Lakeside Living

7 Listings
525 W LAKESIDE Drive, 117, Tempe, AZ 85281

$495,000 525 W LAKESIDE Drive, 117
Tempe, AZ 85281

Welcome to Bridgeview at Hayden!

$450,000 140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 402
Tempe, AZ 85281

945 E Playa Del Norte Drive, 1015, Tempe, AZ 85288

$470,000 945 E Playa Del Norte Drive, 1015
Tempe, AZ 85288

525 W LAKESIDE Drive, 124, Tempe, AZ 85281

$499,000 525 W LAKESIDE Drive, 124
Tempe, AZ 85281

140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 203, Tempe, AZ 85281

$949,000 140 E RIO SALADO Parkway, 203
Tempe, AZ 85281

420 W 1ST Street, 323, Tempe, AZ 85281

$460,000 420 W 1ST Street, 323
Tempe, AZ 85281

previous next

MLS IDX Listing Disclosure © 2023

Copyright 2023 Arizona Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved. Information Not Guaranteed and Must Be Confirmed by End User. Site contains live data.

RailLife Posts

Looking For A REALTOR To Rock The Rail Life

Nowhere To Eat In Downtown Mesa

Could Coyotes Help Expand Tempe Streetcar?

Scott Smith Remaining as Valley Metro CEO

Banta Lawyers Up – Sues Valley Metro for $1.65 Million

© 2023 · RailLife · Developed by Marketing Press